Monday, May 12, 2008

The Plastic Grocery Bag

Whip. Flap. Flap. Whip. Whip. What's that noise? Just a plastic grocery bag stuck high in a tree in our backyard. How long has it been there? Quite a while. Where did it come from and how did it get so high in the tree?

Drive down Eastchase. Exit onto Division. As you take the loop around, try to count the number of plastic bags you see. It may take you a few hundred trips to be able to spot them all.

Cleaning up these plastic bags costs the city over a million dollars every year. Who pays for that? We do.

Thankfully, Arlington is discussing banning the plastic grocery bag. I am all in favor of it. Paper bags would be easier to recycle and easier to control if littered. To go one step further, we could bring environmentally friendly bags with us to the store each time we shop. If we provided our own bags, that's less cost for the store to provide the bags, which may be passed on to us in savings. So this proposal to ban plastic bags makes sense economically (for the city, for property value, and for our grocery costs) and environmentally (both for recycling and neighborhood litter).

With that said, how's the best way for the city council to handle it? Before they just make the decision themselves, I think receiving public response and educating the public as to the benefits would be very wise. Some like the handles on plastic bags, thus objecting to the change. However, the canvas bags that can be re-used have handles as well. Also, many places have paper sacks with handles (Braum's for example). Encouraging local supermarkets to voluntarily remove plastic bags while publicly praising the ones that do (free advertising) might make the transition smoother. If they won't budge, then the council should move forward to do what's best for the community. But grocery stores shouldn't be given a lot of time to comply. Wal-mart, for example, shouldn’t need much time to remove their plastic bags. If they are able to move the merchandise they do, they can move out the plastic bag as well.

Unfortunately, many people view all environmental improvements as some conspiratorial agenda by "liberal evil forces." Forcing the issue right away just feeds that irrational fear. (As an aside, mentioning San Francisco as an example the city is following doesn't help with this group either.) But, I think through partnering with grocery stores and educating the public as to the economic and environmental benefits, perhaps the fears of those opposed to anything "environmental" can be alleviated, and we can take a step to make Arlington a cleaner, more attractive place to live.

6 comments:

D said...

You're in the closet. The Democrat closet, that is. I just know it.

Emily K said...

I don't think you're a closet democrat. I think you're a good steward of this earth as God tasked man to be. Honestly, this is something that I never thought about. Thanks for enlightening me.

Ben said...

I'm gonna tell mom on both of you and then i'll inherit everything. muhahahaha

pianos said...

I'm leaving my inheritance to Ben, the sane choice! MOM

Charlie Goodyear said...

Banning plastic bags, one more government intrusion into private lives. Whatever happened to personal responsibility? We have litter laws. Are they enforced? No. So let's just ounish everyone. Who owns the land? Tell them to clean it up and cite and fine them if they don't. Actually assign a cop to watch some grocery store lots for folks who litter, cite them, and publicize it. If they have time to write me a ticket for my parked car at church not having an up to date inspection sticker, they can spend some time trying to save the $1.3 million alleged to be casued by plastic bags.

As for saving money, that's a fantasy as rediculous as the government infecting blacks with the AIDs virus. There will be no reduction in city expenses or taxes. There will be no reduction in grocery prices. If anything, they'll be higher. the better paper bags cos more.

Besides, I thought we had to get rid of paper bags and replace them with plastic so that we could be more environmentally friendly?

Your suggestion to publicize the problem and seek some cooperative change is a whole lot better than a government mandate. I agree with that suggestion 100%.

Austrian stores charge a fee for each bag. That sure cuts down on the demand and encourages folks to bring their own.

D said...

I don't think Whole Foods charges for plastic bags...but I do think they credit you something like five cents if you bring you own. I think...

And I'm sorry...I didn't mean to loose Jack his inheritance.